Caribbeanmuslims.com - http://www.caribbeanmuslims.com
Can Islam and Secularism dialogue with each other?
http://www.caribbeanmuslims.com/articles/1190/1/Can-Islam-and-Secularism-dialogue-with-each-other/Page1.html
Maulana Waris Mazhari

 
By Maulana Waris Mazhari
Published on 05/3/2010
 

(Translated from Urdu by Yoginder Sikand)

The question of whether or not there can be a dialogue between Islam and secularism is a particularly pertinent one today. Many Muslims, including the vast majority of ulema and Islamists, believe that these ideologies are polar opposites. Hence, they insist, there is no possibility of arriving at even a minimum consensus between the two.

Yet, the question of dialogue between Islam and secularism remains one of particular importance, especially in the context of the rights of Muslims living as minorities in non-Muslim-majority countries. Numerous non-Muslim scholars and even some noted Muslim intellectuals (such as the Pakistani writer Mubarak Ali, the Indian Islamic scholar Maulana Wahiduddin Khan, and the late Professor Mushirul Haq) complain that where Muslims are in a majority, they brand secularism as ‘anti-Islamic’ and a threat to Islam and its followers, but where they are in a minority, they regard it as a blessing. Furthermore, where they are in a minority, they seem to argue for a secular state but, at the same time, insist that Muslims must remain safe from secularism.